Rental Properties and Coast FIRE Using Cash-Out Refinancing to Grow Your Portfolio

Rental Properties and Coast FIRE: Using Cash-Out Refinancing to Grow Your Portfolio

Having enough equity for another down payment doesn’t necessarily mean you’re ready for another rental. The first property may be worth considerably more than it was five years ago. You’ve paid down the mortgage, rents have risen, and buying again looks possible without touching your retirement investments.

A cash-out refinance can provide the money. It also replaces the mortgage on a property that’s already earning income, so you’ll need to work out what the new payment would leave you with each month.

For someone pursuing Coast FIRE, that deserves a careful look. Another property could help build wealth over the next decade while doing very little to make a shorter working week affordable now.

Borrowing Against the Property You Already Own

With a cash-out refinance, you take out a larger mortgage and use it to pay off the existing loan. You receive the remaining money after closing costs and can put it toward another rental purchase.

A DSCR cash-out refinance may be an option for investors who want financing based primarily on a property’s rental income rather than their employment income. Credit history, property value, and other lender requirements still affect approval.

There’s a limit to how much equity you can access. The lender will finance only a certain share of the property’s value, and the replacement loan may have a different rate or repayment schedule. Before deciding what to do with the proceeds, check what those terms would cost you.

When a Second Rental Adds Just $50 a Month

Take a rental worth $400,000 with $200,000 left on the mortgage. In this hypothetical example, a lender agrees to refinance up to 75% of its value. The new loan is $300,000, leaving $100,000 before closing costs once the old mortgage is paid off.

That’s a substantial amount to put toward another purchase. It’s also borrowed money you’ll repay with interest.

Suppose the first rental currently leaves you $600 a month after expenses and the mortgage payment. Under the new loan, that falls to $150. You use the refinance proceeds toward a second rental, which brings in $500 a month after its mortgage, operating expenses, and allowances for repairs and vacancies.

You now own two properties producing a combined $650 a month. For taking on another building and another loan, you’ve added $50 to your monthly income.

There may still be good reasons to buy. As the mortgages are paid down, you could build equity in both properties, with potential appreciation adding to that over time. But the immediate improvement in cash flow is small, and you’ll have more property to look after.

Will the Extra Income Let You Work Less?

Once your retirement investments are on track to grow toward your eventual target without further contributions, Coast FIRE lets you turn your attention to covering current expenses. Rental income might help you reduce your hours or choose a job that pays less.

For that to work, you need a realistic figure for the rent you can keep.

When including income-producing assets in your Coast FIRE calculations, separate the cash available for living costs from the growth you’re counting on for retirement. A property’s estimated value tells you something about your wealth. It doesn’t tell you how much of next month’s spending it can cover.

In the example above, another $50 probably won’t change your work schedule. You might still want the second rental because of what it could be worth in ten or fifteen years. That could still work out well, as long as you can afford to carry the extra debt in the meantime.

What the New Loan Could Cost You

Look closely at the mortgage you’d be giving up. If you locked in a low rate years ago, refinancing could mean paying a higher rate on the entire new balance. Closing fees add another cost. Some loans also carry prepayment penalties, which can matter if you sell or refinance again sooner than expected.

How you use the money affects the tax treatment as well. The deductibility of mortgage interest on rental properties depends partly on where the borrowed funds go. Keep records of how you spend the proceeds, including any amount used to purchase the next property.

Then consider the bills that won’t arrive on a convenient schedule. A roof might need replacing just as a tenant moves out. An insurance renewal could come in higher than you’d allowed for.

Even when your projections include those expenses, you still need cash available to pay them. Reserves become particularly useful when you’ve increased the debt on one property to buy another. Without that cushion, an ordinary rental problem could leave you borrowing again or selling retirement investments you intended to leave alone.

When Keeping One Rental Makes More Sense

Before refinancing, try the numbers under less comfortable conditions. Allow for lower rent, a vacancy, or an expensive repair. Could you carry both mortgages through the shortfall? Would your reserves cover it without drawing on retirement savings?

Consider the extra work as well. A second property brings another set of maintenance needs and tenant issues, even if the investment looks promising over the long term.

You may decide the opportunity is worth it. Equally, there’s no need to expand simply because you’ve built enough equity to qualify for a loan. If your existing rental provides dependable income, keeping it as it is may give you more room to cut back at work than a second purchase that barely changes your monthly cash flow.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *